Just as I'm committed to publishing
positive reviews of the new books of verse that I most enjoy here on
Rogue Strands, all with the aim of helping them find a wider
readership, so I'm also aware that poetry blogging and reviewing can
adopt many different but equally valid approaches. One such example
is Dave Poems, run by Dave Coates.
I've been reading his blog since 2011,
initially intrigued by his use of a disclaimer at the beginning of
each review, in which he states any prejudices or connections with
the poet in question. I've always found the posts a maelstrom,
especially the earliest ones. They were daring, provocative,
forthright, sometimes a car crash and sometimes extremely perceptive.
Above all, they were the work of someone who was wrestling with his
own views of poetry.
To write and offer up such reviews for
public consumption takes a lot of guts. Moreover, as time has gone by
and Coates' work has evolved, he hasn't hastily removed those first
articles. Instead, he's done an excellent job of placing them into a
personal and general context, recently publishing a remarkable
retrospective post on his first fifty reviews.
In the afore-mentioned piece, Coates
encourages “the understanding that negative criticism is not a
personal attack, and that personal attacks are not good criticism.”
In other words, he might now be choosing his words with greater
awareness of their consequences and the potential for personal hurt,
but that won't stop him criticising or praising poetry as he sees
fit.
Dave Poems is already a terrific
blog. The coming months and years, however, promise even more. I know
Coates' views are going to challenge my preconceptions, and that's
invariably a good thing!
DISPLACED They called her aloof, impractical, clumsy, plain. It was, they
say, difficult for her not to fall in love.In spite, that is, of the first
coughs...
Dear Matthew
ReplyDeleteHow many other reviewers tell you honestly and exactly what they think of the slim poetry volume in front of them? None that I can think of! I had more or less given up reading poetry reviews because 99% of them were brown-nose jobs.
Best wishes from Simon R. Gladdish